188. Coming Out at Thanksgiving
Coming out to family can be an emotional experience, but doing so around Thanksgiving brings its own unique set of challenges. Between family expectations, holiday traditions, and the possibility of unexpected reactions, coming out at Thanksgiving can turn a familiar family gathering into a life-changing moment.
In this episode, we're exploring the complexities of coming out as gay during the holidays, from navigating difficult family conversations to managing expectations and finding acceptance. Whether you're preparing to come out, reflecting on your own experience, or supporting someone in the LGBTQ+ community, we're unpacking what it means to bring your whole self to the Thanksgiving table.
Related Episodes:
- Listen to Episode 35. Surviving the Holidays
- Listen to Episode 77. Coming Out
- Listen to Episode 123. My Coming Out Story
Additional Resources:
- The LGBTQ+ Holiday Survival Guide: Navigating the Season’s Joys and Challenges
- The Journey of Coming Out: Understanding Its History and Significance
- Coming Out: A Guide to Self-Discovery, Acceptance, and Living Authentically
- Coming Out at Thanksgiving
- How to Come Out on Thanksgiving
- How to Come Out at Thanksgiving
00:00 - Snarky Opener
00:23 - Episode Introduction
00:41 - Coming Out at Thanksgiving
01:07 - Tarot
02:08 - The Origins of Coming Out at Thanksgiving
05:40 - Why Come Out at Thanksgiving?
07:27 - Tips for Coming Out at Thanksgiving
08:59 - Chosen Family and Friendsgiving
10:10 - Episode Closing
11:17 - Connect with A Jaded Gay
0:00 – Snarky Opener
I'm gay. Also, this tofurkey is delicious.
0:23 – Episode Introduction
Hello, my LGBTQuties, and welcome back to another episode of A Jaded Gay.
I'm Rob Loveless, and today I am a non-jaded gay because I recently registered for my final semester of grad school. It has been a long couple of years, and now the end is finally in sight. I'll be graduating this May, so it's the final countdown.
0:41 – Coming Out at Thanksgiving
Anyway, from giving thanks to almost being done with grad school to Thanksgiving, today we are going to be talking about a kind of niche gay culture topic, and that is coming out on Thanksgiving.
Last year, I did a bonus episode on this concept of coming out on Thanksgiving, which I had seen in a few pop culture moments, and I was curious if it was a real thing. So, we'll be diving into it, but first, tarot time.
1:07 – Tarot
Ooh, we got a jumper, and what that means is when you're shuffling the deck, a card falls out, which is sometimes just because I'm bad at shuffling cards. But in tarot, people consider this a jumper and a card that the universe is handing to you, and our jumper today is the Three of Pentacles in Reverse.
Pentacles is a Minor Arcana card that's tied to the element of earth. It's feminine energy, so it's asking us to reflect and meditate, and pentacles is a very nurturing, grounding energy that's tied to putting in the hard work and prosperity. Literally, it's financial prosperity, but sometimes I like to think of it as emotional prosperity.
In numerology, three is tied to creativity, collaboration, and community. And when we draw the Three of Pentacles in Reverse, it's telling us that we might be feeling a lack of confidence or an overwhelming fear of stepping out of our comfort zone, but this card is telling us now is the time to address that fear.
We may be feeling at odds with others, or there's a lack of respect between you and someone else, so we need to set clear guidelines around respect and collaboration and acknowledge everyone's unique contributions to achieve a sense of balance or harmony.
So, with that in mind, let's pass the turkey and get into this bad boy.
2:08 – The Origins of Coming Out at Thanksgiving
Hello, my LGBTQuties, and welcome to your November bonus episode.
Since we are coming up on the holidays and Thanksgiving is just around the corner, I wanted to focus this month's bonus episode on coming out during the holidays, and more specifically, coming out on Thanksgiving.
In past episodes, we covered the concept of coming out, the history of National Coming Out Day, and even my own tragic coming out story. But something that I noticed in pop culture is queer people coming out on Thanksgiving, and one of the earliest depictions I remember seeing of this is Will & Grace.
In the Season 7 episode titled "Queens for a Day," Will is trying to win over Annette, the mother of his boyfriend Vince, played by the beautiful Bobby Cannavale, by preparing the family's traditional Thanksgiving meal.
And during this, Vince's sister Ro confides to Jack that she's a lesbian and plans to break off her engagement to a man and come out during the family dinner. And Jack is encouraging her to come out while Will pleads with her to wait so that Thanksgiving can go perfectly as he tries to impress Annette.
In fact, at one point, Will says to Ro that Thanksgiving is traditionally when gay men come out, and that lesbians come out at Christmas. And of course, shenanigans ensue.
And when I first saw this, I thought the concept of coming out during a holiday dinner seemed odd.
I mean, this is probably my own internalized homophobia, but I always thought like, oh, that's one way to upset people during the holidays by doing that. But also, beyond that, it just seems like it would cause a lot of attention, and it might be overwhelming to come out to so many people at once. And if it doesn't go well, you have to stay at dinner and sit uncomfortably. So, it always seemed a bit weird to me.
But since then, I've seen similar scenarios in other TV shows, so it seems to be a thing. In fact, when I got older, I watched all of Will & Grace from start to finish, and in Season 2, Jack also comes out to his mother on Thanksgiving.
So, with all that in mind, I was curious if there was something to this.
And from doing some research, the earliest literature I could find about coming out on Thanksgiving is a November 2012 article from Philly Mag. Hey, represent. It's titled "Coming Out at Thanksgiving."
And in it, author Natalie Hope McDonald references a GayDating.com survey that found that 55% of people surveyed said they planned to come out to their families at the dinner table on Thanksgiving.
Additionally, 10% said they planned to surprise their families by bringing home a same-sex partner.
Now, I tried to do a little more research into this survey, but GayDating.com is no longer in existence. And since the survey is almost 15 years old, we might need to take those findings with a grain of salt.
Regardless, in the article, Dr. Lori Eichelberg, a licensed psychologist, gave this insightful quote:
"The family atmosphere at Thanksgiving is very warm and loving, and many closeted gay singles feel left out because they cannot be themselves or share the holiday with their partners or boyfriends."
Additionally, in 2013, a Slate article titled "How to Come Out on Thanksgiving" dubbed the holiday as America's unofficial coming out day. However, they only referenced strong anecdotal evidence and the imprecise survey data in the Philly Mag article we talked about.
In it, they interviewed Kristen Russo, the co-founder of Everyone Is Gay, which is an organization that offers advice and support to LGBTQ+ youth and their parents.
And Russo had to come out to her parents on Thanksgiving when she was 17, and she explains that coming out at Thanksgiving is very common, especially for college students since that's their first holiday home.
But beyond those few articles, there isn't much else out there. Nevertheless, while there isn't hard data about coming out at Thanksgiving, it definitely seems to be a thing.
5:40 – Why Come Out at Thanksgiving?
And from all that quote-unquote research, there seems to be a few reasons why LGBTQ+ people may consider coming out at Thanksgiving.
First off is the fact that the whole family is gathered. With aunts, uncles, cousins, and grandparents present, it gives you the opportunity to tell everyone at once.
And you don't have to worry about having the conversation over and over. You can just get it over with and move on, like ripping off a Band-Aid. Or anal sex.
Next, Thanksgiving tends to give people warm, fuzzy feelings. It's kind of like the kickoff of the family holiday season, and family holidays tend to focus on trying to foster a warm and loving atmosphere, and the key word there is try.
But because of this atmosphere, people may feel like it's safer to be vulnerable and come out.
Also, there's this sense of tradition and honesty around Thanksgiving. It's when we typically come together with our families and express what we're grateful for. And usually there's an atmosphere of gratitude around our health and being with loved ones.
So, these kind of conversations can create a feeling of authenticity and naturally segue into being truthful about our identities.
Next is the practical timing of Thanksgiving. Depending where you work, you probably have off Thanksgiving Day and the day after, which gives you a nice long weekend.
Meanwhile, other holidays like Christmas can fall on any day of the week, and employers usually only give you the day off.
So given that, people may feel like they have space afterwards if they come out on Thanksgiving Day. You know, they'll have the rest of the weekend to process reactions, debrief with friends, and recover emotionally in case things don't go well.
And lastly is the pop culture reinforcement. Like we talked about, there are a lot of pop culture references ranging from sitcoms, films, and essays, which have built Thanksgiving into a coming out trope.
So, these pop culture scenarios may help motivate someone to come out at Thanksgiving, or they may even feel it's an appropriate or expected moment.
7:27 – Tips for Coming Out at Thanksgiving
So, with all that in mind, and going back to the Slate article, here are a few tips for how to come out at Thanksgiving, if you choose to do so.
So, the first is be direct. The Slate article suggests short-circuiting the whole process by saying something like, "I'm gay, pass the gravy."
Or, "I've been meaning to tell you, I'm gay. Also, this tofurkey is delicious."
Now, while this bluntness may be a little over-exaggerated, it helps to remove pressure, minimize build-up, and keep the focus from spiraling into over-analysis.
Next, build support through allies. Start by coming out privately to a sibling or trusted family member who you know will be accepting and can provide backup for when you come out to everyone.
Not only does this make the coming out process seem less isolating, it also helps to ease tension, keep emotions in check, and take some of the pressure off the whole family.
And lastly, avoid gimmicks.
And when I hear that, the scene from Steel Magnolias immediately comes to mind when Clary tells her friends that her nephew told his family that he had a brain tumor and had three months to live. Then he said, "Hey folks, I'm only kidding, I'm just gay."
So yeah, not the best approach.
But another popular gimmick to avoid is bringing home a quote-unquote special friend for the holidays and then coming out and revealing they're actually your partner.
The article refers to this as a bait-and-switch tactic, and if your family doesn't take the news well, then you're all trapped.
Or there's the risk that your family will kick your special friend out. And obviously that's the worst-case scenario, but regardless, this can lead to awkward dynamics.
So, your best bet is to come out solo and lead with honesty.
8:59 – Chosen Family and Friendsgiving
And with all that in mind, the holidays can be a tough time for LGBTQ+ people, since this time of year really focuses on family dynamics and some of us may have strained relationships with our family members.
So, if that is the case for you, don't forget about the concept of chosen family. And specifically, as it relates to Thanksgiving, Friendsgiving has been growing more and more popular each year.
Sure, some people may host a Friendsgiving before the holidays just to get together with their friends. But plenty of people also host Friendsgiving in place of a formal Thanksgiving holiday with their biological families.
So, whether you're out and have a good relationship with your family, or are out and don't have a good relationship with your family, or are still in the closet, make sure you take time during the holiday season to spend time with your chosen family in an environment where you feel safe and affirmed.
And regardless of whether or not you come out at Thanksgiving this year, I certainly hope that everyone listening and the turkeys get stopped.
Oh my god, go to church! Oh, pardon.
Anyway, I'd love to hear your thoughts. Coming out at Thanksgiving, is it a real thing or not? And have you done it? Let me know.
And as always, thank you so much for supporting the podcast on Patreon. I really appreciate it.
And I will see you all next month. Mmm-bye.
10:10 – Episode Closing
And connecting it back to the tarot, the Three of Pentacles in Reverse, again, this card is telling us we might not feel confident or we're afraid, and there's some tension with those around us. But it's time to address it.
And as it relates to this episode, you know, our family is our first community. And when you realize you're different, it can be really scary because you're afraid that what makes you different might isolate you from them.
But maybe it's time to let the fear stop holding us back and be honest with our family about who we truly are.
It's not always easy, and maybe they don't receive it the way we want them to, and maybe there's even some arguments where we feel disrespected.
We can't control their reaction, but we can control how we take care of ourselves. And that's when we set guidelines or boundaries with our family as we need to if we're trying to create a sense of harmony and maintain relationships with them.
And for some people, unfortunately, that's not an option. But remember, the number three is tied to community, so it's important we find those people who are our chosen family, our safety nets, in case we don't have the coming out experience we were hoping for.
And at the end of the day, it doesn't matter if it's on Thanksgiving or a random day of the year.
We need to feel safe and come out on our own terms to validate our own identities, because we all deserve to be seen, loved, and respected.
11:17 – Connect with A Jaded Gay
So, thank you all for listening. I hope you enjoyed that kind of niche subject.
If you have any feedback or questions, you can email rob@ajadedgay.com.
Also, let's keep the conversation going. Head on over to our official Discord server, the LGBTQutie Lounge, to connect with myself and other listeners.
Please remember to rate, review, and subscribe. Five stars only. I greatly appreciate it.
For more information on this topic, episode resources, blog posts, merchandise, links to socials, all that fun stuff, you can visit the website ajadedgay.com.
You can connect with the podcast on Instagram, TikTok, SoundCloud, and YouTube @ajadedgay.
You can follow me personally, Rob Loveless, @rob_loveless.
Also, if you're feeling generous, consider supporting the podcast on Patreon for as little as a dollar a month. That gets you instant access to episodes ad-free a day early, plus exclusive monthly bonus content, just like the episode you heard today.
Or if you just want to access monthly bonus episodes, you can purchase them for $3 each.
And if you're scared of commitment, don't worry, I get it. You can make a one-time donation on Buy Me A Coffee for any dollar amount, and both the Patreon and Buy Me A Coffee are @ajadedgay.
And remember: every day's all we have, so you gotta make your own happiness. Mmm-bye.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
Pandora
iHeartRadio
Castro
Podchaser
PlayerFM
Deezer
Podcast Addict
PocketCasts
TuneIn
RSS Feed